Attorney General Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation

Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and the Division on Civil Rights (DCR) announced today the filing of a lawsuit in federal court against the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) over its months-long failure to respond to lawful subpoenas seeking information about the treatment of detainees at Delaney Hall, the private immigration-detention facility in Newark owned and operated by The GEO Group, Inc.

View Complaint

In the wake of reports of alarming conditions and recent deaths of detainees held at the facility, Attorney General Davenport and DCR issued an investigative subpoena to GEO Group in August. The investigation focuses on whether GEO Group employees violated the civil rights of people detained at the facility. GEO Group has claimed that it cannot respond to the subpoena without DHS’s permission.

Today’s lawsuit asks the court to find that DHS has unreasonably delayed its response in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act. It also asks the court to set a firm deadline by which DHS must communicate its decision.

“There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling,” said Attorney General Davenport. "We will continue to do all we can to ensure that these civil detainees are treated with the dignity and decency that all people are entitled to under the law.”

“Individuals housed in an immigration detention facility do not waive their constitutional and legal right to receive adequate medical care or to be protected from violence,” said Yolanda N. Melville, Director of the Division on Civil Rights. “People who have been held at Delaney Hall have shared extremely troubling accounts—as have the families of those who died. The federal government’s silence in response to our lawful requests for information speaks volumes.”

On August 7, 2026, the Attorney General and DCR opened an investigation into potential violations of detainees' civil and constitutional rights under the New Jersey Civil Rights Act and the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination. As part of that investigation, DCR issued a subpoena to GEO Group seeking records related to the provision of medical care to detainees.

DCR issued a subpoena to GEO Group after at least three individuals died while in GEO Group's custody at Delaney Hall. Public reports have alleged inadequate medical care, the rapid spread of communicable diseases, abuse by staff, unreasonable exposure to violence, and other harms.

As the complaint details, GEO Group declined to comply with the subpoena, asserting that it required authorization from DHS under DHS’s internal regulations. GEO Group claimed that pursuant to those DHS regulations, it had promptly forwarded the subpoena to DHS’s general counsel to provide GEO Group authorization to comply.

While the State maintains that GEO Group, as a private business operating on its own property within New Jersey’s borders, is mistaken in thinking it needs DHS authorization to comply with the subpoenas, it nonetheless began following up on its requests with DHS directly as an alternative pathway to obtain the necessary information. For over three months, and despite multiple follow-up inquiries from Attorney General Davenport’s office to DHS, DHS has failed to respond. DHS has not authorized production of any information, nor has it stated whether it will or will not do so.

The State's ongoing investigation has identified reports of serious deficiencies in medical intake and screening, failures to provide medications for chronic conditions, inadequate responses to medical emergencies, failures to protect individuals from physical and sexual harm, denial of accommodations for individuals with disabilities, and routine denial of language interpretation services.

Attorney General Davenport and DCR believe that based on the reports gathered so far, there is a serious risk of further harm to those housed at Delaney Hall, including additional death and disease.

DHS’s failure to respond to DCR’s subpoena is part of a pattern of stonewalling any efforts to examine conditions inside Delaney Hall. Litigation in a separate lawsuit over GEO Group’s refusal to allow a full health inspection is ongoing.

The State argues that DHS's prolonged silence, combined with a pattern of obstructing State and municipal oversight, has unreasonably delayed the investigation and prolonged risks to detainees' health and welfare.

In today’s lawsuit, New Jersey is asking the court to compel DHS to communicate a decision regarding compliance with the subpoena.

News From Around the Web

The Political Landscape