Montvale and the Crossroads of Data Centers and Mount Laurel

Montvale Mayor Mike Ghassali

BY COLLEEN O'DEA

For decades, affordable housing has been among the most hated terms among New Jersey municipal officials, as many communities fought to stop the construction of homes they said would bring too much growth and change the character of their communities.

But data centers could eclipse Mount Laurel housing, with as many as 110 municipalities having passed ordinances banning the siting of the facilities that residents are complaining bring too much noise and use too many precious resources in enabling high-speed data processing, sometimes for artificial intelligence, according to news reports.

Those two issues were part of a court case Wednesday involving Montvale, a Bergen County community that had led the unsuccessful fight over the state’s 2024 affordable housing law revision. As part of its affordable housing plan, required for all municipalities that want to avoid being sued and forced to build a high-density development, Montvale has an agreement with a developer to put both homes and a data center on a 40-acre redevelopment site.

The law signed by then-Gov. Phil Murphy was supposed to improve the affordable housing process in New Jersey and get low-cost units built more quickly, yet the system remains complex. Municipalities have to draft detailed plans, pass ordinances and go through a dispute resolution program should they be challenged. Any further issues are resolved through the Superior Court.

Wednesday’s hearing on Montvale’s housing plan held by Bergen County Superior Court Judge Lina Corriston wound up addressing only preliminary matters. The issue likely won’t be resolved until sometime next year.

Montvale is among a relatively small number of municipalities whose plans are still being ironed out. According to the Cherry Hill-based Fair Share Housing Center, which has been the state’s main champion for affordable housing production and most painful thorn in the side of municipal officials opposed to the Mount Laurel housing, about 50 of more than 400 municipalities who had adopted zoning ordinances still have not fully complied with the law. Once in full compliance, a municipality will be shield from builder’s remedy lawsuits that could require them to allow much denser development than zoning permits. The builder’s remedy has been used since the early days of the Mount Laurel Doctrine, the series of state Supreme Court decisions that prevent towns from undertaking exclusionary zoning and require all municipalities provide their fair share of needed affordable housing.

It’s still unclear how many homes will be built in what is known as this housing Fourth Round, a 10-year period that began last year. Housing advocates have said the state needs more than 200,000 affordable units to meet all the need. The Department of Community Affairs calculated the prospective housing need, for new construction, at around 85,000 homes. A review of the initial housing plans in February 2025 (that I did for NJ Spotlight News at the time) found that the total obligation calculated by participating municipalities was 61,000, and the state had estimated that more than 100 municipalities that chose not to file housing plans had an obligation of an additional 6,000 homes. A municipality’s obligation does not necessarily translate into that number of units because towns can get bonus credits for allowing certain types of low-cost housing, such as apartments for people with special needs, developments within a half mile of public transit stations and homes with more than three bedrooms. And municipalities don’t have to build the affordable housing units, just zone for their construction.

Still, Fair Share is confident that “tens of thousands of affordable units” will result during this Fourth Round, said Jag Davies, a spokesman.

“It's worth noting that as part of their Fourth Round plans, towns have to also demonstrate compliance with prior Rounds, so that has prompted a lot of municipalities to move forward with Third Round production that had been stalled,” Davies added.

About 21,000 new affordable homes – 70,000 total – were built during the prior round as of July 2024, according to a Fair Share estimate.

For this round, Montvale and Mayor Michael Ghassali had led opposition to the requirements of the 2024 law, joining with other towns to file unsuccessful state and federal suits against it. The U.S. Supreme Court ended the challenges when it declined to hear an appeal earlier this year.

The borough did draft and file an affordable housing plan. At one point, a developer had proposed a traditional inclusionary development for the property. It would have comprised 250 homes, of which 50 would have had price controls so they would be affordable to those of low- or moderate-income. In Bergen County’s housing region, which includes Hudson, Passaic and Sussex counties as well, a family of four with an income as high as $103,600 could qualify for moderate-income housing. Then last December, the borough submitted an amended plan that put 50 affordable units and a data center on the site, along with a PILOT – payment in lieu of taxes – agreement.

According to representatives for Montvale and the developer, the site’s zoning permits a data center and the plan is for a 322,000-square foot enterprise data center, not an AI center. Enterprise data centers typically are owned and operated by a business for its own purposes. AI data centers, also called hyperscale centers, power artificial intelligence and cloud computing and use more electricity for power and water for cooling. Their lawyers told Corriston that there is no reason Montvale’s housing plan should not be approved.

“There's nothing in this agreement that's unusual or inappropriate legally or outside the context of what normally happens in a Mount Laurel case,” Michael Edwards, attorney for Montvale, said. “We have to comply with every single source of law … Due process protections will be protected.”

Fair Share disagrees. Its attorney, Joshua Bauers, said Montvale’s agreement with the developer “sets a troubling precedent.” Of the PILOT tax break, Bauers added, “In effect, it creates a way for the developer to bypass meaningful public review and secure financial benefits it wouldn't otherwise be entitled to. That's a fundamental misuse of New Jersey's affordable housing process.”

Wednesday’s nearly three-hour hearing was only to consider the scope of a “fairness hearing” to determine if the agreement between Montvale and the developer is “fair and reasonable to the interests” of low- and moderate-income households in the region and consistent with state law and the Mount Laurel Doctrine, Corriston said. That hearing is not likely to happen until early March. Corriston reserved decision on Wednesday’s arguments.

News From Around the Web

The Political Landscape