Pennacchio v. Mastrangelo

This is a tale about Donald Trump, New Jersey finances, “illegals” and a bruising state Senate Republican primary in Morris and Passaic counties.

The first thing to keep in mind is that just about nothing rankles Republicans these days as much as illegal immigration.

So it’s no real surprise that border crossings are an issue in the LD-26 primary, where incumbent Joe Pennacchio is being challenged by Tom Mastrangelo, a Morris County commissioner.

Yes, yes, immigration is a federal issue and this is state government, but when passions are high, logic can take a back seat.

The state finance part of our story dates back to New Jersey’s fiscal 2019-20 budget.

When that budget was passed almost four years ago, something strange happened. Many Republicans, including Pennacchio, voted yes. The vote in the Senate was 31-6.

In partisan times, that was quite the rarity. Pennacchio explained recently that he voted “yes,” because this budget was less than what Gov. Phil Murphy originally proposed, and what’s more, it raised no taxes.

However, Team Mastrangelo claims that it included $3.1 million to provide legal services to those here illegally.

A statement by Mastrangelo’s campaign this week references a story from that time period in the Asbury Park Press. It says:

“Last year, Murphy allocated $2.1 million to legal aid that would help people in immigration court, where individuals are not guaranteed a lawyer. The budget bumps that up to $3.1 million.”

The statement adds, “Joe (Pennacchio) either does not know what he is voting for, or is forgetting what he voted for.”

Time out, says Pennacchio.

He suggests that his opponent either does not know what he’s talking about, or is just “lying.”

Pennacchio points out that the adopted budget normally differs from the governor’s introduced budget and he said that is what happened here. Money to provide undocumented individuals with lawyers was not in the adopted budget. Anyone who cares can examine the budget and see for themselves, he said.

And he noted that if that money was in the 2019-20 budget, no Republican would have voted for it.

Where does Trump fit into all this?

Well, Trump, who, of course, was president at the time, actually sent out a tweet congratulating the Legislature on a good budget. More specifically, the then-president said lawmakers deserve credit for “not passing (higher) taxes that would have driven large numbers of high end taxpayers out of the state.”

Pennacchio, not surprisingly, saved the tweet, which dates back to July 1, 2019. After all, it’s hard to see Trump lauding a budget that offers financial support for undocumented individuals.

Still, don’t expect this to be the end of it.

Subsequent Mastrangelo campaign messages have sought to tie Pennacchio to the current situation on the southern border.

The one meant to terrify voters the most shows hordes of people congregating under the headline “800,000 illegal Immigrants at the southern border.”

The rather tenuous connection here is that Pennacchio’s vote four years ago inspired what’s happening today.

Also being raised is an accusation that the Murphy administration aims to give undocumented individuals $53 million in aid, including one-time payments to some of $500.

One problem here, of course, is that the budget Pennacchio supported four years ago did not include the original aid in question. Additionally, that referenced $53 million was stripped from last year’s budget and even if it wasn’t, Pennacchio did not vote for that budget anyway.

As we said, illegal immigration is a major issue for the country.

Don’t expect it to go away regardless of the facts involved.

(Visited 1,140 times, 1 visits today)

4 responses to “Pennacchio v. Mastrangelo”

  1. The fact is illegal boarder crossings are down by 40% since Title 42 expired. . The hoards were a myth. Another Red Scare. Moreover, our legal system guarantees representation in a court of law, no matter who you are. So, to budget for such representation is good economics, and good leadership.

  2. Please this is a race for the worse and the worser. Neath candidate has ever addressed an issue that was important to residents in the 26LD. It has always been focusing on what divides people.
    Why aren’t they ever discussing over development? Something that is on the minds of every resident in the district. Both Pennacchio and Mastrangelo live in Montville Twp. The zoning and planning board meetings are filled with frustrated VOTERS, where are their solutions to fix this problem? No one cares about immigrants in the township you both live in.

  3. Nice spin Fred. Inaccurate but clever. One thing that does rankle people is opinion disguised as reporting.

    Frankly, the past two years of Biden and the influx of some two million illegal aliens should rankle everyone.

    I’m not advocating for either NJ candidate, but as a news outlet, report news. If writing an opinion please state so.

    As for illegal immigration, we have a fairly robust legal immigration system. What is needed is a system that encourages assimilation into America society.

    This includes learning English, obeying laws, working and not relying on government taxpayer handouts.

    We need military at the border, with illegal border crossers apprehended and deported. Strong border walls helpful, a lesson learned courtesy of the state of Israel.

  4. With all the talk about illegal immigrants/aliens getting additional monies for legal aid, I have one question: Why are illegal aliens/immigrants, who’ve committed criminal acts by crossing the U.S. Border without proper authority to get entitlements, be allowed any legal aid whatsoever??? Especially, when real Americans cannot get legal aid in the corrupt courts of New Jersey.

    Let’s remember that Illegal Aliens cost New Jersey over $4 BILLION DOLLARS ANNUALLY!!!!! And, they contribute less than $150 MILLION DOLLARS ANNUALLY by way of taxes!!!! A lot of their money is made in cash, and they send it home to Mexico or Central American countries they came from. Ever watch a Walmart line for Western Union or other money transfer entity??? They almost ALL illegal immigrants sending money to other countries–our tax money!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

News From Around the Web

The Political Landscape